American University
School of International Service
International Peace & Conflict Resolution Program
33.696.05
 

GENDER AND CONFLICT:

FEMINIST PERSPECTIVES ON WAR, PEACE & INTERNATIONAL POLITICS

Dr. Simona Sharoni Office: Dunblane 208 
Fall 1998 Office hours
3 credits Wed. 5-8 PM & by appointment 
Tel: 895-4927 
e-mail: ssharon@american.edu
Course Objectives  
Requirements 
Required Texts  
Course Outline 
Related Resources

Course Description

The proposed course will explore questions of conflict and cooperation from a variety of feminist perspectives. The course is designed to introduce gender as a significant category of analysis for the study of local and global politics in general and such phenomena as peace, war and security in particular. The course will critically examine the construction and transformation of gender identities and roles during both times of conflict and transition towards resolution. Using a comparative case study approach, we will explore the interplay between gender and politics in three different settings: South Africa, Northern Ireland and the Israeli-Palestinian context with a particular emphasis on women's movements and struggles in each of those contexts. 
 

Course Objectives

  • To provide students with a general overview of the relevance of gender to the study of peace and conflict resolution and of the main bodies of literature and other resources available in this area
  • To highlight the relationship between the academic study of gender and its workings in the ‘real world’ 
  • To assist students who seek to develop to turn feminist theory and gender studies into one of their areas of expertise and concentration

Course Requirements and Grading

 1. Class participation: 10%  

Although this is a graduate seminar, you are expected to attend all classes. No-attendance or late appearances will be excused only if you contact me before class. Three or more unexcused absences or a pattern of late appearances may be grounds for a failing grade in the course. In addition to regular attendance, my assessment of your class participation will not be based merely on how many times you spoke in class. I am aware that people have different styles of expression and levels of comfort with speaking in a group. To allow less vocal students an opportunity to express themselves, I will occasionally ask for your written feedback about the readings and/or class discussions. You will be given the option to post your reactions on the course’s electronic listserve or to simply hand them in to me. 
 

2.  Critical review of Scholarly Journals: 15%

The objectives or this assignment are to acquaint you with the growing body of literature on gender, conflict and international politics, to examine the differences and similarities in the ways in which they are addressed in peace, conflict resolution and international politics journals and in women’s studies/feminist journals and to develop a bibliography of related readings to compliment the course syllabus. 

Your task would be to examine all the articles on gender and conflict published in the past decade in a feminist journal and do the same for a peace/conflict resolution or international politics journal. Based on your examination of these journals, you are to write an essay comparing the state of gender-related research in peace and conflict resolution studies to women’s studies (broadly defined). Your essay should address the following questions: 

1. Has there been a change in the amount and nature of research on gender published in the past decade? 
2.  Can you draw any conclusions about the kinds of articles on gender that seem to get published and the type of journals that seem more or less receptive to work on gender? 
3.  Are there any recurrent themes or issues that emerge in the published research?
Your essay should consist of 6-8 typed and double-spaced pages. Due Sep. 17 

List of  feminist journals: 

Women & Politics 
Signs: Journal of Women in Culture and Politics 
Women's Studies International Forum 
Gender & Society 
NSWA Journal (A publication of the Women's Studies Association) 
Feminist Studies 
Feminist Issues 
Feminist Review 
Differences: A Journal of Feminist Cultural Studies 
Gender & History 
Journal of Gender Studies 
Journal of Women's History 
 

List of peace, conflict resolution and international politics journals: 

American Political Science Review 
British Journal of International Studies 
Bulleting of Peace Proposals 
Conflict Studies 
Cooperation and Conflict 
Foreign Affairs 
Foreign Policy 
Journal of Conflict Resolution 
Journal of Peace Research 
International Studies Quarterly 
Peace and Change 
Peace Review 
Political Psychology 
World Politics 
 
 3. Group project: 25%  

The objective of this assignment is to give you an extra incentive to familiarize yourself with the background to the three conflicts explored in this course with particular attention to the interplay between gender and politics. 

You will be divided into groups of 4-5 students with each group focusing on one conflict. The assignment has three parts: 

Part 1 involves the preparation of an up to date chronology of the conflict and an analysis of 

the conflict. Please be sure to answer the following questions: 

(1) What are the major turning points in the history of this conflict? 

(2) Who are the main parties to the conflict? 

(3) What are their positions on the conflict, its history, current dynamics and its resolution? What is considered the preferred resolution for various parties? 

(4)What according to the parties are the main issues or problems involved in the conflict? Can you identify patterns of similarity and difference in the parties' perceptions and definitions of the issues involved? 

(5) What are the major points of contention between the parties? Are there any points of agreement? 

(6) How would you describe the relationship between the parties? (pay particular attention to differences and similarities in power, culture and other dynamics of identity as well as to the transformation of the relationship over time). 

(7) Have there been attempts to resolve the conflict in the past or in the present? 

(8) Who played the role of third party and what were the objectives of those interventions? 

(9) What are your ideas for a successful intervention designed to resolve the conflict? (who should be the third party? what type of intervention? when? where? etc.). 

Based on your report, which should consist of 4-5 typed and double-spaced pages, you are expected to make a brief class presentation (10-15 minutes) and lead discussion about the conflict you examined. Due Sep. 23 

Part 2 involves the preparation of an annotated list of web-sites on the conflict with a particular (but not exclusive) emphasis on sites dealing with gender issues. Your list should consist of the site’s name, the correct address (for example: http://www.cnn.com) and a brief description (no more than 2 sentences of the particular site). Your list should include at least 12 sites. Due Sep. 24. 

With your permission, I would like to post the results of these assignments on the course’s web page. 

Part 3: Building upon your careful examination of the conflict, you are now faced with the challenge of communicating what you have learned to others. Rather than another theoretical presentation, your task is to prepare a brief (10-15 minutes) audio-taped radio program focusing on the interplay between gender and conflict with particular attention to the transformations that may occur in gender identities and roles after peace agreements are signed. Please note that since your program should be designed for a general audience, you must provide people with some basic information about the conflict. Due Nov. 24. 
 

4.  DC-Activism Report: 10% 

The objective of this assignment is to acquaint you with the various DC-based organizations dealing with issues related to gender and conflict. You have a choice of either preparing a general profile of an organization or interviewing one of its leading figures. You will receive more instructions for this assignment in class and a preliminary list of organizations and groups in the area. Due Oct. 22 
 
 5.  Final paper: 40% 

This assignment is designed especially for those of you who wish to focus your theses or SRPs on gender, war and peace. You will receive detailed instructions and personal supervision designed to enable you to conduct original research and write a solid research paper that could serve as the basis for your SRP or thesis. 

  • Rough draft due Nov. 19 
  • Final paper due Dec. 10 
 

Required Texts

    Begonia Aretxaga, Shattering Silence: Women, Nationalism, and Political Subjectivity in Northern Ireland. Princeton University Press, 1997. 

    Jacklyn Cock, Women and War in South Africa, Cleveland, OH: The Pilgrim Press, 1993. 

    Simona Sharoni, Gender and the Israeli-Palestinian Conflict: The Politics of Women's Resistance. Syracuse University Press, 1995. 

    Cynthia Enloe, The Morning After: Sexual Politics at the End of the Cold War, California University Press, 1993. 

    Jan Jindy Pettman, Worlding Women: A Feminist International Politics, Routledge, 1996. 

    Selected articles (packet to be distributed in class)
 

Course Outline

1. Sep. 3 Introduction 
 
I. Feminist Theorizing on War, Peace and International Politics

2. Sep. 10 Feminist Theory and Gender Studies for Beginners 

    Joan W. Scott, "Gender: A Useful Category of Historical Analysis," in Elizabeth Weed ed. Coming To Terms: Feminism, Theory, Politics (New York: Routledge, 1989), pp. 81-100. (reading packet) 
    R. W. Connell, "Gender as a Structure of Social Practice", in Linda McDowell and Joanne Sharp, eds. Space, Gender, Knowledge: Feminist Readings (London: Arnold, 1997), pp. 44-52. (reading packet) 
    Donna Haraway, "Situated Knowledges: The Science Question in Feminism and the Privilege of Partial Perspective", in Linda McDowell and Joanne Sharp, eds. Space, Gender, Knowledge: Feminist Readings (London: Arnold, 1997), pp.53-72. (reading packet)
 
3. Sep. 17 Making Feminist Sense of International Politics: Central Issues and Debates 
    Cynthia Enloe, "Gender Makes the World Go Round", in Linda McDowell and Joanne Sharp, eds. Space, Gender, Knowledge: Feminist Readings (London: Arnold, 1997), pp. 447-458 (reading packet). 
    Simona Sharoni, "Towards Feminist Theorizing in Conflict Resolution" (reading packet). 
    Enloe, pp. 161-200 
    Pettman, pp. 3-84.
II. Gender and Conflict in Comparative Perspective:
South Africa, Northern Ireland and Israel/Palestine

4. Sep. 22 (Tue.) Analyzing conflicts from a peace and conflict resolution perspective 

    Cock, pp. 1-25, 213-228 
    Aretxaga, pp. 3-23 
    Simona Sharoni & Mohammed Abu-Nimer, "The Israeli-Palestinian Conflict: Analysis and Prospects for Resolution", in Understanding the Contemporary Middle East, ed. Deborah Gerner, Boulder, CO: Lynne Rienner Press (in press) (reading packet). 
 
5. Sep. 24 Analyzing Conflicts with Gender Sensitive Lenses 
    Cock, pp. 26-53 
    Aretxaga, 24-79 
    Sharoni, pp. 1-30 
     
III. The Gendered Politics of War and Peace
  

6. Oct. 6 (Tue.) Women and Peace 

    Linda Forcey, "Women as Peacemakers: Contested Terrain for Feminist Peace", Peace & Change, Vol. 16, No. 4, pp. 331-354. (reading packet). 
    Lynne Woehrle, "Feminist Debates about Nonviolence", in V.K. Kool, ed. Nonviolence: Social and Psychological Issues (Lanham, MD: University Press of America, 1993) (reading packet). 
    Pettman, pp. 107-125
7. Oct. 8 Women and War 
    Cock, pp. 95-148, 186-212 
    Enloe, pp. 201-227 
    Pettman, pp. 126-156 
    Christine Sylvester, "Patriarchy, Peace and Women Warriors", in Linda Rennie Forcey ed. Peace: Meanings, Politics, Strategies, (New York: Praeger, 1989) (reading packet) 
     
8. Oct. 14 (Wed.) Militarized Masculinities in Context 
    Enloe, pp. 10-37, 71-101 and 142-160. 
    Cock, pp. 54-94 
    Pettman, pp. 87-106 
    Steve Niva, "Tough and Tender: New World Order Masculinity and the Gulf War", in Marysia Zalewski and Jane Parpart eds. The "Man" Question in International Relations (Boulder, CO: Westview Press, 1988), pp. 109-128. (reading packet). 
     
9. Oct. 15 The Interplay of Militarism and Sexism  
    Enloe, 142-160 
    Simona Sharoni, "Homefront as Battlefield: Gender, Military Occupation and Violence Against Women." In Women and the Israeli Occupation: The Politics of Change, ed. Tamar Mayer. London and New York: Routledge, 1994, pp. 121-37.
 
IV. Gender and the Politics of Resistance
 

10. Oct. 21 (Wed.) Gender and Nationalism 

    Enloe, 228-251 
    Sharoni, pp. 31-55 
    Nira Yuval Davis, "Gender and Nation", in Linda McDowell and Joanne Sharp, eds. Space, Gender, Knowledge: Feminist Readings (London: Arnold, 1997), pp. 403-408. (reading packet). 
    Ann Mclintock, "No Longer in a Future Haven: Gender, Race and Nationalism", in Linda McDowell and Joanne Sharp, eds. Space, Gender, Knowledge: Feminist Readings (London: Arnold, 1997), pp. 409-425. (reading packet)
    Margaret Randall, "Women in Revolutinary Movements: Cuba and Nicaragua", in Women in World Politics: An Introduction (Westport, CT: Bergin & Garvey, 1995), pp.183-198. (reading packet).
11. Oct. 22 Women’s and Men’s Struggles for Social and Political Change 
    Simona Sharoni, "Middle East Politics through Feminist Lenses: Toward Theorizing International Relations from Women’s Struggles", in Linda McDowell and Joanne Sharp, eds. Space, Gender, Knowledge: Feminist Readings (London: Arnold, 1997), pp. 425-445. (reading packet).
    Aretxaga, pp. 80-145 
    Sharoni, pp. 31-110 
    Cock, pp. 149-185
--Oct. 29, Nov. 5, Nov. 12 – No class: independent work on group projects

12. Nov. 19 The Potential and Pitfalls of Transnational Alliances and Solidarities 

    Chandra Talpade Mohanty, "Feminist Encounters: Locating the Politics of Experience", in Linda McDowell and Joanne Sharp, eds. Space, Gender, Knowledge: Feminist Readings (London: Arnold, 1997), pp. 82-97(reading packet) 
    Deborah Stienstra, "Organizing for Change: International Women’s Movements and World Politics", in Francine D’Amico and Peter Beckman eds. Women in World Politics: An Introduction (Westport, CT: Bergin & Garvey, 1995), pp. 143-154. (reading packet)
    Sharoni, pp. 110-130 

    Eilish Rooney, "Political Division, Practical Alliance: Problems for Women in Conflict", Journal of Women’s History, Vol. 6, No. 4 (Winter/Spring 1995), pp. 40-48. 

 
V. Gender and the Politics of Conflict Transformation

13. Nov. 24 (Tue.) The Morning After: Making Feminist Sense of Peace Agreements and their Aftermath 

    Enloe, pp. 38-70, 102-141, 252-262 
    Aretxaga, pp. 146-175 
    Sharoni, "Peace as Identity Crisis: Gender and Political Change in Israel/Palestine and the North of Ireland", Millennium: Journal of International Politics (under review) (reading packet)
--Group projects due – radio show  

14. Dec. 3 Future Directions in the study of gender and international conflict 

Summary, Integration and Feedback 

 

Internet Links and Resources

Please note: Inclusion of a link on this page does not constitute endorsement by me of the views expressed on the pages hereby linked. This list is intended for those who want to explore issues further, and is intended to include multiple voices and perspectives. Along those lines, if there are views and pages relevant to these issues which you would like to see included, please feel free to contact me at ssharon@america.edu
 
 
Feminism/Feminist Resources 

Women's International Center 
Virtual Sisterhood 
Inform--Women's Studies Archive at the University of Maryland 
University of Wisconsin Women's Studies Librarian Office 
Women's Resources project 
Feminism/resources 
FeMina --"Yahoo for Women" search engine 
 

 

Gender & Social Change: Movements & Organizations 

Feminist/Women's Activism  
Women's Studies: Activism -- www.1.arcade.uiowa.edu/gw/wstudies/activism.html 
Feminist Activist resources on the Net: http//www.igc.org/women/feminist/html 

 
Women &  Peace 

Women's International League for Peace and Freedom 
Greenham Common Women 
Bat Shalom: A feminist peace meavement, working for peace, democracy, and a greater inclusion of women in governmental affairs in Israel 
4Mothers: An Israeli women's group calling for a unilateral withdrawal of Israel from Southern Lebanon. 
 

The first "wave": Women's Movements for Suffrage 

Contemporary Movements & Organizations 

International Organizations Working For Women's Rights  

United Nations 



Violence Against Women  
    Women for Women in Bosnia: An organization devoted to helping Bosnian women (regardless of nationality) who have been victimized by the ravages of war. 


Women and the Military  

Reproductive Rights  International  See Also:   


Beijing Conference on Women 

Overview on the Fourth World Conference on Women 
Final Edition of the Platform forAction 
Speeches Look under "late breaking news" 
Women's Web World 
WomensNet 
The World's Women On-Line 
UN Division for Advancement of Women 
 

 Women in Political Office 

    Fifty plus One An organization devoted to bringing the participation of women in U.S. political office into balance with the proportion of women in the population as a whole. 
    The Mining Company's 9/15/97 feature article on "Why So Few?" 
    Emily's List: A PAC dedicated to supporting the candidacies of women running for the US Congress. 
    Women's PAC's (a list maintained by the Center for American Women in Politics [see below]). 
    Center for American Women in Politics: This academic organization housed at Rutgers University in New Jersey is dedicated to promoting " greater understanding and knowledge about women's relationship to politics and government and to enhance women's influence and leadership in public life". See in particular, their:  A Collection of Articles on Women and Politics maintained by a scholar at the University of Maryland. Many of the articles are about women within the Democratic and Republican parties. See a favorite of mine, "Feminism v. Family Values" 
Female "Office" Holders Online  Janet Reno Other Sites on Women, Elections and Voting    



Women and Government in Selected Regions of the World   
    AVIVA's Global Gallery: AVIVA is an international Women's Listing Magazine which posts the news and events of women around the world. The Global Gallery is wonderful. It has region subheadings (listed below) which give lists of meetings and events for women's activism, but also (and this is the reason I love it so much) it lists news events (government actions, etc.) that effect women in each of the regions of the world. AVIVA is a "football free zone." 
Asia  Australasia  Middle East  Africa 
    AVIVA's Africa listing 
    Solid Africa (An organization devoted to supporting "the economic empowerment of women in areas of socio-economic crisis and hardship. It supports women who have already started their businesses by enhancing their access to credits, funds, technologies, marketing, management and training."~From Solid Africa's "Mission Statement"). 
Europe 
    AVIVA'Europe Listing 
    The Position of Women in Norway: read about the demands of the Norwegian women's movement (not for equality, but something else) and the public culture surrounding gender that has developed (See, for example, the notes about paternity leave). 
North America  South America 

Women and Work   Women, Work and Economics  Harassment and Discrimination   
This page was created by Amy Shuster & Simona Sharoni and is maintained by Simona Sharoni Last updated 08/29/98